I see Rachel Corrie as a misguided soul whose naïveté led to her untimely
death.
But I ask again, WHY the double standard?
Where was she when twenty eight people were massacred at a Passover Seder?
Where was she when twenty teenagers ( by a mere 5 min would have included my
cousin) were killed in a Pizzeria.
I do not support everything that the Sharon government does, but they are
defending themselves against people who simply want the deaths ( or
conversion)of all Westerners, especially us Jews... They are trained from
the age of six to be "martyrs".Check out the literature of Hizbollah and
other Islamic groups. This is certainly not all Moslems, but it is goal the
people who are carrying out these outrages.
It would be just as bad under a more Liberal Israeli government.
Rachel Corrie was not Julia Butterfly Hill. And she was certainly not a
pacifist. And it was tragic accident.
Unlike those massacres at Passover and at the Pizzeria.
L
- Original Message -----
From: mayhem <meurtre_at_earthlink.net>
To: <OliveStarlightOrchestra_at_yahoogroups.com>
Sent: Thursday, March 27, 2003 3:16 PM
Subject: Re: [OliveStarlightOrchestra] Re: Rachel "The Human Waffle"Corrie.
> Re: John's feedback
>
> > I found message #666 by Mike worth responding to. Sorry, but the
> > Rachel Corrie jokes posted earlier were in poor taste; nor I did not
> > find them especially funny.
>
> I think you have to be in the right mood for gallows humor. But anyone
> who has laughed at a princess Di joke or a JFK Jr. joke should be able
> to live with these. (And . . . John! Would you like a reprise of some
> of your youthful jests?)
>
> > I think there is a similarity between Rachel Corrie and John Walker
> > Lindh: Both were young people from affluent backgrounds, idealists
> > thinking they have figured out what's wrong with the World and wanting
> > to fix it. Imagine how driven they were - they left the comfort of
> > their homes to struggle aloung with others in troubled Third World
> > countries...
> >
> > I would say that being young, at least they have an excuse for such
> > behavior! I think Mike's point of view is too harsh. Rachel would
> > probably have changed her views on things if she had lived long enough.
> >
> > I have met people who joined organizations to help people in Africa,
> > and lived there a few years. Sometimes even longer than that. They
> > went over very excited and idealistic with a desire to help out
> > oppressed peoples, and returned with a more realistic view of things:
> > It's not as simple as they had thought.
>
> What Mike said: there is a different between humanitarian assistance and
> fomenting violence among people who have had plenty of it and simply long
> for peace.
>
> --Joy
>
> >
> > --- In OliveStarlightOrchestra_at_yahoogroups.com, "Mikal" <mikalm_at_i...>
> > wrote:
> >> Sharose (and everyone else),
> >>
> >> I have zero regard for this waste of space and oxygen, who has now
made
> >> herself the woman to beat in the 2003 Darwin Awards.
> >>
> >> Why?
> >>
> >> * Rachel Corrie was not some Palestinian toddler who wandered into
> > the path
> >> of an earthmover and got mowed down. She was an allegedly educated
> > adult
> >> who traveled halfway across the world, into a war zone, with the
> > sole intent
> >> of inflaming an already insane and deadly situation. The group she
> > worked
> >> there with has a stated goal of "armed liberation" of the Palestinian
> >> region. Maybe I'm a little slow, but "armed liberation" seems to imply
> >> shooting, war, violence, that sort of thing. Is it any wonder she met
a
> >> violent end under their tutelage?
> >>
> >> * She tried to agitate a mob of Palestinians against the U.S. and
> > Israel by
> >> burning an improvised American Flag in their midst. Don't believe me?
> >> Check out these two pics, and then wonder why you haven't seen them
> > in the
> >> mainstream media:
> >>
> >> http://homepage.mac.com/cfj/.Pictures/rachel-corrie-flagburner.jpg
> >>
> >> http://homepage.mac.com/cfj/.Pictures/rachel-corrie-flag-02.jpg
> >>
> >> Does this look like the face of a loving, tolerant, nurturing
> > person? Or
> >> does it look like someone with serious anger problems, who chose
> > political
> >> violence rather than therapy as a way to deal with personal demons?
> >>
> >> * The bulldozer was a huge, armored ('dozer drivers get sniped at
> > regularly
> >> in these areas) vehicle with virtually zero visibility except at
> >> straight-ahead 12-o'clock. I've know people who've worked on
> > construction
> >> sites and road crews, and they've all said to NEVER get near a mobile
> >> earthmover for this reason...and they were talking about
> > garden-variety ones
> >> half the size of this behemoth.
> >>
> >> * As I said earlier, she was in a war zone -- the bulldozing was an IDF
> >> operation, and was accompanied by a troop detail. Anyone not a
trained,
> >> armed combatant who enters such an area is taking an unimaginably
stupid
> >> risk with their life, and should be prepared to die in an ugly manner.
> >>
> >> * According to more than one eyewitness, she wasn't even standing in
> > front
> >> of the 'dozer. Those pics of her standing were taken earlier in the
> > day, at
> >> different sites (note that the shadows, light, and even the machine
> > seem to
> >> be different). The witnesses said that in but sitting on a mound of
> > earth
> >> well out of the sight range of the driver. It is quite possible
> > that she
> >> was killed not by being run over, but by the collapse of the earth
> > mound as
> >> the 'dozer caved it in from the side.
> >>
> >> * Whatever the scenario or exact cause of death, did she really
> > think she
> >> could get away with playing chicken with a moving 40-ton vehicle whose
> >> driver couldn't see her clearly? Maybe my folks were a bit strict,
> > but from
> >> an early age I was taught not to run in front of cars for this
> > reason. I
> >> guess all that edumacation at Evergreen State University, and all those
> >> activist circle-jerks, convinced her that the laws of physics and
common
> >> sense didn't apply to such an enlightened and progressive womyn as
> > herself.
> >>
> >> * If she was so much against war and killing, then why did she waste
her
> >> time protecting ABANDONED BUILDINGS? Why didn't she, say, try to
> > stop one
> >> of the suicide bombings that claims Israeli lives on a weekly basis?
> > The
> >> answer: she was a moral coward who went up against Israel and America
> >> because they were CIVILIZED DEMOCRACIES UNDER THE RULE OF LAW, who
allow
> >> idiots like this huge amounts of latitude to interfere with
> > government and
> >> private activities in the name of free speech. The very reason this
> > case is
> >> so publicized -- unlike, say, the ones about slave-freeing missionaries
> >> being murdered in the Sudan -- is that it's an ANOMALY in Israel.
> > Losers
> >> like Corrie are looking for cheap and painless ways of making
themselves
> >> moral authorities and martyrs, since they can't advance themselves
> > through
> >> careers, relationships or other productive means of finding one's
> > identity.
> >> A REAL radical humanitarian -- one who was GENUINELY concerned about
> > REAL
> >> oppression and murder -- would have gone to Iraq, North Korea, the
> > PA, or
> >> any kleptocratic Third World toilet, and fought the epic brutality and
> >> bloodlettings in such places. And of course, would have been
> > whacked the
> >> second they opened their mouth.
> >>
> >> Rachel Corrie has now joined the Idealistic Idiot Sisterhood,
> > alongside Amy
> >> Biehl, Lori Berenson, and Rosebud DeNovo -- disturbed, deluded women
who
> >> thought that their personal convictions justified their stupid
> > politics, and
> >> would protect them from the consequences of their suicidal antics.
> > I know,
> >> I know...it's their FEEEEEELINGS that are important. Well, I'm sure
> > that
> >> Road-Pizza Rachel had strong FEEEEELINGS. But because those strong
> >> FEEELINGS weren't balanced by personal responsibility or common
> > sense, she's
> >> now not FEEEELING anything at all.
> >>
> >> In closing, I would say that my sympathy for some poor Iraqi draftee
> > eating
> >> sand and dodging bullets on behalf of a monster like Saddam, is about
> >> 100,000 times that of mine for a deranged, self-hating terrorist
enabler
> >> like Rachel Corrie. The political culture and gene pool is
> > healthier in her
> >> absence.
> >>
> >> Mikal, the Heartless Reactionary Warmonger Zionist
> >
> >
> > Yahoo! Groups Sponsor
> > To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
> > OliveStarlightOrchestra-unsubscribe_at_yahoogroups.com
> >
> >
> >
> > Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service
> > <http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/> .
> >
>
>
>
> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>
>
>
> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
> OliveStarlightOrchestra-unsubscribe_at_yahoogroups.com
>
>
>
> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
>
Received on 2003-03-27 19:19:39
